McDonald's is expected to report third-quarter earnings before the bell on Wednesday, and the most telling number may be the one investors are bracing for. Wall Street analysts surveyed by LSEG expect the company to report results, and StreetAccount estimates point to same-store sales in the U.S. declining 0.5%. For the company's home market, that is not a rough patch. It is a sign that something in the core business is not working.
CEO Chris Kempczinski has already admitted the problem. Last quarter he said the chain's U.S. business fell short, hurt by uneven execution of its value offers and complicated launches of new menu items. Those are two different failures, and both sit squarely in the company's own hands. Value is supposed to be McDonald's strongest argument with budget-conscious customers. If it is executed unevenly, customers notice, and the message becomes confusing. Complicated menu launches compound the damage by slowing restaurants and frustrating the staff who must run them.
The decision to name Skye Anderson as the new U.S. president is a reasonable response, but a leadership change is not a strategy. The real test is whether the company can deliver consistent value across its restaurants and keep new menu launches simple enough to execute well. Those are operational questions, and they will be answered by what happens in kitchens, drive-throughs, and at the counter, not in executive announcements.
Investors have already voiced their doubts. Shares have fallen about 11% over the last year, weighed down by concerns about the U.S. business, expensive plans to upgrade restaurants, and the broader economy. With a market capitalization of roughly $186 billion, the company has room to absorb a difficult quarter, but it cannot afford to treat its domestic weakness as temporary noise. Investors will be listening closely to commentary about the fourth quarter so far, especially after Chipotle Mexican Grill executives said last Wednesday that the restaurant industry saw traffic soften in October.
What should happen next is straightforward. McDonald's should be direct with investors about the causes of the U.S. decline, show a clear plan for simplifying value and menu execution, and justify the cost of restaurant upgrades in terms of sales that customers will actually see. Wednesday's report will not settle the matter, but it will show whether the company is prepared to fix the basics first.