Drivers caught up in the car finance mis-selling saga have waited long enough, so it is welcome that Barclays has begun making early compensation offers before the legal fight over the Financial Conduct Authority's central scheme is settled. Claimants who want money sooner should be able to take it. The FCA has said it expects only a minority of claimants to receive early offers, and that most will still have to wait for the outcome of next year's court case.
The key condition is that no one should be pushed into a worse deal than the central scheme would give them. The FCA has said lenders must be clear about what acceptance means. Under those terms, a customer who accepts can keep the payment even if the final settlement proves smaller, cannot claim more later if the legal challenge leads to bigger payouts, and loses access to the financial ombudsman. Those are heavy consequences, and many people facing a monthly bill will not have the time or expertise to weigh them carefully.
The regulator should therefore monitor these offers closely, as its general counsel Stephen Braviner Roman has said it will. Its planned factsheet and published list of lenders making early offers are sensible steps, because they give drivers a reference point before they sign anything. Lenders should also be required to show their calculations clearly, using the FCA's own methodology, so customers can check whether an offer matches what the scheme would pay.
The wider problem is that the background to this saga should not be forgotten. Millions of drivers who took out car loans between April 2007 and November 2024 were not told about the commission dealers received through discretionary commission arrangements. The industry faces costs of up to £9.1bn. Those costs are a consequence of lenders' past conduct, not a burden that drivers should be asked to accept at a discount.
Anyone who has not yet complained should do so directly with their lender, and the FCA's free guidance is a good place to start. Early money is useful, but it should never come at the price of a settlement that falls short of what the law says drivers are owed.